Best Gift Cards in Wisconsin (2025) - Expert Tested and Reviewed
From Milwaukee to Green Bay: The Gift Cards Wisconsinites Count On
I’ve tested the best gift cards in Wisconsin across Milwaukee’s Bay View and Third Ward, Appleton’s College Ave, and quick stops through Wausau and Oshkosh. These top gift cards in Wisconsin are built for real life: snow days, farmers’ markets, youth sports, and those last-minute detours to Hilldale in Madison. The picks below include popular gift card options that hold up in-store and in-app—fast scans, clear balances, and no awkward “try again” moments at checkout.
Some cards shine for winter (think home and pharmacy runs); others win weekends in Door County and Wisconsin Dells. I favored brands with strong statewide coverage and simple redemption, so the same card works for friends in Kenosha and cousins in Superior. Practical value first, always.
Here are the ten I’d actually gift—tested on weeknights, road trips, and during one memorable sleet storm that turned dinner plans into delivery.
How We Selected the Best Gift Cards in Wisconsin
Over three weeks between Wauwatosa’s Mayfair errands, Sun Prairie grocery loops, and pit stops in Sturgeon Bay and Menomonie, we redeemed each card on mobile and in person. We scored redemption speed, barcode reliability, and how balances behaved with fees, tips, and promos. Every pick was rated on a 5-point scale for practicality, flexibility, appeal to Wisconsin shoppers, and brand reputation.
Local nuance mattered. For travel cards, we checked winter weekend volatility around Door County and Devils Lake. For delivery, we compared dense coverage near UW–Madison with thinner pockets around Marshfield and Rhinelander. We rewarded cards that worked the same on Brady Street as they did in De Pere—and dropped anything that stalled at the register or buried rules in fine print.
Our Picks for the Best Gift Cards in Wisconsin in
Detail
REI Gift Card – Outdoor & Adventure
About a REI Gift Card
REI credit is a no-brainer for Badger State weekends: Ice Age Trail hikes, winter microspikes, kayaks for Chain O’ Lakes, and warm layers for Lambeau seats in December. Redeemable online and in-store, it covers apparel, footwear, camp gear, bike tune-ups, and co-op services. The REI Gift Card in Wisconsin stands out because seasons swing hard; you might need merino base layers in Wausau one month and sun shirts for Door County the next. Redemption is quick, returns are friendly, and sale events stretch value if you time a pickup. Outdoorsy grads, new homeowners, and cabin regulars will put this to work fast.
Pros:
- Season-ready picks: Year-round gear from traction devices to bug nets means the balance stays useful no matter the forecast.
- Easy returns: Co-op policies and clear receipts simplify sizing exchanges after gifting without awkward conversations.
Cons:
- Premium pricing: Some items run higher than outlet chains; timing purchases around member sales maximizes value.
- Stock swings: Peak season items can sell out in popular sizes; online order to store pickup avoids wasted trips.
What our testers say:
“I used $100 toward a Smartwool base layer ($115) at REI Brookfield before a Minocqua weekend. Barcode scanned fast; curbside pickup saved me in a sleet burst.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.8/5 – Gear, apparel, and services cover four true seasons without locking recipients into one activity.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.7/5 – Works online or in-store with broad brands and sizes plus workshops and tune-ups.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.8/5 – Perfect for cabin trips, state parks, and cold game days across the state.
- Brand Reputation: 4.7/5 – Co-op credibility, fair policies, and durable gear build long-term trust.
- Overall Score: 4.75
Ace Hardware Gift Card – Home & DIY
About a Ace Hardware Gift Card
Old houses, long winters, and proud lawns—Ace sees a lot of action here. You can redeem on snow shovels, ice melt, grill parts, storm-window film, and quick fixes that keep basements dry in spring. The Ace Hardware Gift Card in Wisconsin shines because most neighborhoods have a locally run Ace with staff who know which fastener you really meant. Balances are easy to use on paint and blade sharpening; weekend projects panic less when pickup is minutes away. It’s the card I hand new homeowners in Oshkosh and friends who keep their Weber working through Christmas.
Pros:
- Neighborhood convenience: Short drives and helpful staff reduce project delays when a $2 part derails the whole day.
- Seasonal coverage: From ice melt to sprinkler fixes, the card adapts to winter and summer needs without waste.
Cons:
- Smaller selection: Not every store stocks specialty tools; ordering ahead prevents mid-project surprises.
- Price variance: Some items cost more than big-box; loyalty promos and bundles help even things out.
What our testers say:
“Threw $40 at a metal shovel ($27.99) and ice melt in Appleton. The cashier applied the balance in one scan; I was salting the steps ten minutes later.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.9/5 – Everyday fixes and seasonal supplies mean the card rarely sits unused.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.5/5 – Hardware, paint, and services cover many quick needs even on tight timelines.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.7/5 – Perfect for winter storms and spring tune-ups across suburbs and small towns.
- Brand Reputation: 4.6/5 – Strong neighborhood presence with friendly service and reliable stock.
- Overall Score: 4.68
DoorDash Gift Card – Food Delivery Service
About a DoorDash Gift Card
Snow, late practice, or a busted dinner plan—delivery saves the day. DoorDash credit covers local staples and groceries with real-time tracking that behaves well in apartment buildings. The DoorDash Gift Card in Wisconsin is especially handy in Milwaukee and Madison, but pickup extends reach in smaller towns. Balances can cover orders, fees, and DashPass for frequent users. It’s the most universal “I thought of you” when time is tight and the roads are worse. Send it digitally and you’ve converted a stressful night into a solved one.
Pros:
- Statewide coverage: Dense options in big cities plus pickup elsewhere keep the card useful through all seasons.
- Versatile value: Funds apply to food, groceries, and DashPass, letting recipients tailor how they save.
Cons:
- Stacked fees: Small-cart and surge fees nibble value; grouping orders or pickup helps stretch balances.
- Rural gaps: Coverage thins in far-north counties; scheduling pickup becomes the smarter play there.
What our testers say:
“Loaded $75 and sent a Bay View friend pho and groceries ($29). Driver messaged for the alley entrance; barcode credit applied automatically at checkout.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.9/5 – A reliable safety net for families juggling practices, work, and winter roads.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.8/5 – Delivery, pickup, and memberships create multiple ways to redeem value.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.7/5 – Strong in metro areas; still helpful elsewhere with pickup options.
- Brand Reputation: 4.6/5 – Clear ETAs and issue resolution built confidence in tests.
- Overall Score: 4.75
Southwest Airlines Gift Card – Travel
About a Southwest Airlines Gift Card
For quick escapes out of MKE or MSN, Southwest credit is low-stress. It applies to Wanna Get Away fares, taxes, and fees, and it’s easy to split across bookings. The Southwest Airlines Gift Card in Wisconsin works for long weekends in Denver or Phoenix when winter drags, or family trips that need two checked bags. Redemption is simple online, and the no-change-fee policy reduces second-guessing when plans shift. Great for grads, conference travelers, and parents visiting kids in out-of-state colleges without guessing exact dates.
Pros:
- Flexible bookings: Apply funds to fares and fees with straightforward rebooking if schedules change later.
- Easy gifting: E-delivery makes last-minute congratulations or travel boosts fast and painless to send.
Cons:
- Route limits: Nonstop options vary by season; connecting flights may be required for certain destinations.
- Fare swings: Busy holidays and storms can nudge prices; monitoring deals stretches card value further.
What our testers say:
“Used $150 toward a MKE–DEN round trip ($218). Code applied instantly; rebooked a day earlier when snow hit without any change fee drama.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.7/5 – Covers real travel costs with policies that respect unpredictable Midwest weather.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.6/5 – Works across fare classes and pairs neatly with points for bigger trips.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.6/5 – Ideal for winter sun getaways and quick family flights.
- Brand Reputation: 4.5/5 – Transparent policies and two free checked bags stay compelling.
- Overall Score: 4.60
Airbnb Gift Card – Travel & Stays
About a Airbnb Gift Card
Door County cabins, Madison game-day walkups, Northwoods lake houses—Airbnb credit flexes with plans. Use it for nightly rates, taxes, and fees, then split costs with friends in-app. The Airbnb Gift Card in Wisconsin is perfect for shoulder-season weekends when hotels fill fast or for families who want kitchens and fire pits. Redemption is instant, and diverse listings make it easy to pivot when prices surge. Great for anniversaries, relocations, and gifting experiences instead of more stuff.
Pros:
- Varied inventory: From studios near Capitol Square to big cottages in Sturgeon Bay, there’s a fit for any group.
- Straightforward app: Clear totals, messaging, and self-check-in reduce arrival headaches and key swaps.
Cons:
- Fee variability: Cleaning and service fees differ; checking final totals protects the card’s value.
- Peak pricing: Holiday and festival weekends can spike; booking early keeps budgets intact.
What our testers say:
“We put $200 toward a Fish Creek cottage ($189 before fees). Code hit right away; keypad check-in saved us when we arrived after sunset.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.6/5 – Useful for unique stays when hotels sell out or get pricey.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.8/5 – Houses, lofts, and cabins meet couples and group needs easily.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.7/5 – Tailor-made for lake trips and festival weekends.
- Brand Reputation: 4.7/5 – Mature platform with dependable support.
- Overall Score: 4.70
Dick's Sporting Goods Gift Card – Sports & Fitness
About a Dick's Sporting Goods Gift Card
From youth hockey tape in Green Bay to trail shoes in Eau Claire, Dick’s covers year-round sport. The card works online or in-store for team gear, fitness accessories, and Packers/Bucks apparel. The Dick’s Sporting Goods Gift Card in Wisconsin is practical because seasons overlap—indoor training, spring tryouts, and fall tailgates. Associates handle size swaps and curbside; stacking with promos makes balances stretch. If you don’t know the exact brand or model, give choice and let them dial it in at pickup.
Pros:
- Wide assortment: Team sports, outdoor, and fitness gear ensure the credit finds a home quickly.
- Promo stacking: Sales and coupons help push value beyond face amount during season changeovers.
Cons:
- Stock gaps: Hot releases move fast; online order to store avoids size and color misses.
- Brand limits: Certain boutique brands may be scarce; checking availability saves a second trip.
What our testers say:
“Used $60 toward youth soccer cleats ($49.99) at Appleton; put the rest on socks. Curbside handoff took under five minutes on a stormy night.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.7/5 – Covers busy family seasons without guessing sizes ahead of time.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.6/5 – Works for apparel, gear, and accessories across sports.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.6/5 – Strong for school teams and tailgate culture statewide.
- Brand Reputation: 4.5/5 – Dependable returns and staff guidance keep it easy.
- Overall Score: 4.60
Best Buy Gift Card – Electronics & Tech
About a Best Buy Gift Card
Winter is home-entertainment season. Best Buy credit covers streaming devices, chargers, headphones, small appliances, and the cable you forgot before the game. The Best Buy Gift Card in Wisconsin is redemption-smooth—online or curbside in Wauwatosa and Madison—and associates will help with quick swaps. Pair it with sale cycles to stretch value on bigger items. For grads, commuters, and anyone whose phone dies in the cold, it’s endlessly practical.
Pros:
- Broad selection: Accessories to major tech ensure the balance finds the right home at any budget level.
- Fast pickup: Curbside and in-store options make tight schedules and snow days manageable.
Cons:
- Deal timing: Values stretch during promo events; off-cycle buys can feel pricier on large items.
- Local sellouts: Hot releases vanish fast; ordering online avoids store-to-store hunts.
What our testers say:
“Spent $45 on a 65W USB-C charger ($49.99) at Wauwatosa. Order-ahead, curbside scan, done in three minutes before school pickup.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.6/5 – Solves constant ‘forgot the cable’ moments and upgrades home setups fast.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.6/5 – Works for tiny accessories or stacking on bigger purchases.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.5/5 – Great for students, remote workers, and winter watch parties.
- Brand Reputation: 4.6/5 – Support and returns keep the experience smooth.
- Overall Score: 4.58
CVS Pharmacy Gift Card – Pharmacy & Essentials
About a CVS Pharmacy Gift Card
Quiet MVP. CVS credit covers cold meds, sunscreen for Devils Lake, snacks for away games, and travel-size everything before early flights. The CVS Pharmacy Gift Card in Wisconsin is redemption-easy at self-checkout, and balances handle most everyday items. It’s the practical gift for new neighbors in Sun Prairie or students settling near UW–Milwaukee. People use this to the last dime without thinking, which is exactly the point of a good gift card.
Pros:
- Everyday coverage: Health, personal care, and grab-and-go groceries guarantee quick, useful redemptions.
- Late hours: Many stores open late; clutch for sick kids, travel restocks, and forgotten supplies.
Cons:
- Exclusions apply: Some services and third-party cards aren’t eligible; a quick terms check avoids surprises.
- Price gaps: Certain staples run higher than big box; coupons and rewards help bridge the gap.
What our testers say:
“Put $25 toward cough drops and tea in Sun Prairie. Self-checkout took the card instantly; ExtraCare clipped to the rest of the basket.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.7/5 – The card people actually finish because it fits everyday needs.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.4/5 – Broad categories, a few exclusions; still very easy to use smartly.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.6/5 – Late hours and many locations map to busy lives.
- Brand Reputation: 4.5/5 – Predictable policies and digital receipts keep it simple.
- Overall Score: 4.55
AMC Theatres Gift Card – Movie Entertainment
About a AMC Theatres Gift Card
When windchill says “indoors,” movies win. AMC credit covers tickets, recliner upgrades, and concessions at locations across Milwaukee-area suburbs and Dane County. The AMC Theatres Gift Card in Wisconsin scans from mobile wallets, works on opening weekends, and makes teen gifting easy. Two seats, a shared popcorn, and escape-from-February vibes—no complicated planning required. Families, date nights, and student budgets all find a good use case.
Pros:
- No blackout dates: Use on premieres, matinees, or midweek showings without fine-print headaches.
- Concessions eligible: Apply to snacks and drinks to gift a full night out, not just the tickets.
Cons:
- Premium surcharges: IMAX and Dolby add cost; budgeting a few dollars extra avoids disappointment.
- Physical loss risk: Lost plastic cards aren’t replaceable; e-gift delivery is the safer route.
What our testers say:
“Redeemed $40 at an AMC in Madison: two recliners and popcorn. Wallet barcode scanned instantly; we were seated before trailers ended.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.7/5 – Works for spur-of-the-moment plans and predictable Fridays alike.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.6/5 – Tickets, seats, and snacks make it easy to tailor a night out.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.6/5 – A cozy winter option statewide that never feels like a chore.
- Brand Reputation: 4.6/5 – Consistent app and service keep it reliable.
- Overall Score: 4.65
Texas Roadhouse Gift Card – Casual Dining
About a Texas Roadhouse Gift Card
Crowd-pleaser status. This card covers hearty dinners that travel well after youth sports or shopping runs. The Texas Roadhouse Gift Card in Wisconsin hits the sweet spot for families in Appleton, Waukesha, and beyond—no one argues with rolls and ribs. Redemption is simple at the table or for takeout; call-ahead helps on busy weekends. It’s a reliable gift for teachers, coaches, and new parents who’d love a night off from dishes, with enough menu variety to keep picky eaters happy.
Pros:
- Family friendly: Big portions and approachable menus make the card easy to use without overthinking choices.
- Dine-in or takeout: Works smoothly either way; leftovers reheat well for late schedules and game nights.
Cons:
- Wait times: Peak hours can stretch; call-ahead or off-peak visits keep kids from melting down.
- Limited dietary range: Fewer vegetarian and allergen-friendly options than some casual chains offer.
What our testers say:
“Used $50 at Waukesha on ribs ($22.99) and kids’ meals; quick swipe and we boxed leftovers for tomorrow’s lunch.”
Tester Score:
- Utility/Practicality: 4.5/5 – An easy ‘no dishes’ card that fits family calendars and budgets.
- Flexibility/Options: 4.3/5 – Dine-in or takeout works well, with dependable portions and packaging.
- Appeal to Wisconsin Shoppers: 4.6/5 – Great after-school and post-game option across suburbs and college towns.
- Brand Reputation: 4.4/5 – Consistent service and value keep it in the rotation.
- Overall Score: 4.45
Comparison of the Best Gift Cards in Wisconsin
REI Gift Card REI Gift Card – Outdoor & Adventure
Quick Look:
Four-season gear for trails, cabins, and cold game days with easy in-store pickup.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
From Ice Age Trail miles to Door County weekends, the card adapts to real seasonal shifts.
Overall Score:
4.75
Ace Hardware Gift Card Ace Hardware Gift Card – Home & DIY
Quick Look:
Neighborhood fix-it essentials from shovels to grill parts with fast checkout.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Reliable for storm prep and summer projects without a cross-town trek.
Overall Score:
4.68
DoorDash Gift Card DoorDash Gift Card – Food Delivery Service
Quick Look:
Meals, groceries, and pickup options with reliable tracking in metro areas.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Clutch on snow days and after late practices when cooking energy is gone.
Overall Score:
4.75
Southwest Airlines Gift Card Southwest Airlines Gift Card – Travel
Quick Look:
Flexible flights from MKE/MSN with easy online redemption and no change fees.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Great for winter sun trips and family visits when weather shifts plans.
Overall Score:
4.60
Airbnb Gift Card Airbnb Gift Card – Travel & Stays
Quick Look:
Book cabins, lofts, and cottages with instant app redemption and shared payments.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Fits Door County getaways and festival weekends without hotel guesswork.
Overall Score:
4.70
Dick's Sporting Goods Gift Card Dick's Sporting Goods Gift Card – Sports & Fitness
Quick Look:
Gear for school teams, gyms, and tailgates with curbside convenience.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Aligns with year-round sports culture from Green Bay to Eau Claire.
Overall Score:
4.60
Best Buy Gift Card Best Buy Gift Card – Electronics & Tech
Quick Look:
From chargers to TVs, quick pickups and easy exchanges keep plans moving.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Winter watch parties and road chargers—practical all season long.
Overall Score:
4.58
CVS Pharmacy Gift Card CVS Pharmacy Gift Card – Pharmacy & Essentials
Quick Look:
Cold meds, sunscreen, snacks, and travel items with self-checkout ease.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Handles the small things that derail plans—fast and close to home.
Overall Score:
4.55
AMC Theatres Gift Card AMC Theatres Gift Card – Movie Entertainment
Quick Look:
Tickets and concessions with mobile wallet scanning and zero blackout dates.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
Perfect winter night out when windchill says “indoor plans only.”
Overall Score:
4.65
Texas Roadhouse Gift Card Texas Roadhouse Gift Card – Casual Dining
Quick Look:
Hearty dinners that travel well with easy table or takeout redemption.
Why It’s Best for Wisconsinites:
A dependable “no dishes” night after practices and errands statewide.
Overall Score:
4.45
Conclusion
Testing these ten across Milwaukee, Madison, and up through Door County confirmed a pattern: Wisconsin shoppers prize usefulness, predictable redemption, and statewide coverage. From quick winter fixes at Ace to last-minute dinners via DoorDash, the best gift cards in Wisconsin slot into busy calendars and unpredictable weather. They also stretch across work, school, and travel without forcing specific dates or locations.
Many Wisconsinites love gifting experiences—Airbnb cabins, movie nights, and road trips—right alongside practical standbys like pharmacy and tech. Whether you’re outfitting a Northwoods weekend, catching a matinee when the wind howls, or fixing a porch step before guests arrive, these cards earn their keep day one and don’t gather dust.
Frequently Asked Questions about the Best Gift Cards in Wisconsin
Where can I buy gift cards in Wisconsin at the last minute?
For last-minute gifting, you’ll find strong selections of gift cards in Wisconsin at Target, Walmart, and CVS stores across Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, and mid-size towns like Oshkosh and Eau Claire. Grocery chains such as Pick ’n Save and Festival Foods keep popular racks near checkout, and many gas stations stock quick options when you’re already on the road. Prefer digital? Retailers and brands offer e-gift cards that land by email within minutes—handy during snow days. If you’re truly in a pinch, buy online and text the code; it’s fast, personal, and avoids shipping delays.
Which gift cards are best for Wisconsin college students?
For UW–Madison and UW–Milwaukee students, food delivery and everyday essentials go far. DoorDash or Uber Eats help during exams and winter storms, while CVS covers cold meds and toiletries without an extra trip. Tech needs pop up constantly, so Best Buy is smart for chargers and headphones; Dick’s works for club sports and intramurals. If parents want to fund weekend resets, Airbnb credit makes it easy to split a cabin near Devil’s Lake with friends. In short, pick cards that trim time and friction for Wisconsin shoppers juggling classes, jobs, and tight budgets.
Do gift cards in Wisconsin expire or charge fees?
Most major brand cards avoid short expiration dates and don’t add monthly maintenance fees, but terms vary, so it’s worth a quick look before gifting. In practice, the best move is to use balances promptly—especially with delivery and travel brands where fees and prices can change. Digital cards are easier to track inside brand apps, and many retailers let you check remaining value online. If you receive multiple cards, plan a small purchase on each so none sit forgotten in a drawer. Clear receipts and app histories make future redemptions painless.
What’s the smartest gift card for Wisconsin winters?
When roads glaze over, practicality wins. Ace Hardware is clutch for shovels, ice melt, and window film, while CVS handles cold meds and grab-and-go groceries. Delivery cards like DoorDash turn a hazardous drive into dinner at the door, and Best Buy covers batteries, chargers, and home-entertainment upgrades for snowed-in weekends. If travel is on the calendar, Southwest Airlines makes rebooking easier when storms shift plans. For Wisconsin shoppers, the best winter pick is the one that solves a problem the moment it appears.
How do I choose between Airbnb and Hotels.com for Wisconsin getaways?
Think about the trip type. For Door County cabins, lake houses, or group stays with kitchens and fire pits, Airbnb offers flexible home setups and shared payments. For quick nights near the interstate, ball tournaments, or when you want predictable amenities, hotel credit can be simpler. In peak seasons—fall colors or festival weekends—book early no matter what. For Wisconsin shoppers planning ahead, compare total costs (cleaning fees vs. resort/parking fees) and cancellation policies, then use the card that best fits your schedule and group size.
What dollar amount should I load for a useful Wisconsin gift?
Match the card to a real scenario. $25–$35 covers takeout for one or a pharmacy run; $50–$75 feels right for family dinners or quality gear accessories; $100+ moves the needle on travel, tech, or seasonal equipment. In Wisconsin, a $50 DoorDash card easily handles a hearty meal for two, while $75 at Ace or REI can fund winter essentials. If you’re unsure, split a budget across two cards—one practical (CVS or Ace) and one fun (AMC or Airbnb)—so the recipient gets immediate utility and a treat later.
Are e-gift cards safe to send in Wisconsin?
Yes—when you buy directly from the brand or a trusted retailer. E-gift cards are ideal for Wisconsin shoppers during storms or tight timelines because they arrive instantly and live inside apps with balance tracking. Always double-check the recipient’s email or phone and save the confirmation until the card is used. If you’re gifting to someone who prefers a physical card, print the code and tuck it in a note. Either way, keep screenshots of balances so replacements are easier if messages get deleted.
Meet our Experts
The merchants represented are not sponsors of the rewards or otherwise affiliated with Earn. The logos and other identifying marks attached are trademarks of and owned by each represented company and/or its affiliates. Please visit each company’s website for additional terms and conditions.
